The sun came out for about an hour this afternoon and I got a chance to
take advantage of it. I loved the color of the light mixed with the wood
of the picnic tables and the green of the grass and the trees. Why,
then, did I end up displaying all the shots I selected from today in
black and white?
I realized that the lines and contrasts between light and dark were the
powerful part of my pictures, no matter how much I liked the colors when
I saw the scene in real life. If the colors were what I liked, I need to
do a better job focusing on that.
I again shot with my 17-40mm f/4 L. Four of the five picnic table shots
were at 17mm (the other was at 40mm). The close-up of the magnolia (or
rhododendron?) was also at 40mm.
I felt an enormous freedom and expansion of my photographic creativity
when I first got that lens. Previously, my widest lens was 28mm wide
which, on the D30, was the equivalent of 45mm. The widest I could go was
essentially normal viewing. I have said many times that I see in wide
angle and that's why the wide angle lenses suit me so well.
I finally realized that the reason I like wide angle shots is precisely
because I do not see in wide angle. I see with the
angle of view of a telephoto lens. When I look through the viewfinder
with "normal" lenses (around 50mm effective) attached, the
scene feels much wider than it looks when I see the scene. It seems to
me that one of the essential traits of a successful photograph is its
ability to present the scene in a way that is different from the way
you would see it with your own eyes. By the nature of photography,
that's going to happen since it represents the three-dimensional
world in two dimensions. But it needs to go beyond that. I don't
have the words or the conscious understanding of this to explain it
well.
The ability of the wide angle lens to easily present scenes in an obviously
false way is at the heart of much of their appeal for me.
And yet the more I look at my photos, the more I see that I am not
handling the wide angle well. I have heard it said that painters create
by adding paint to the canvas while photographers create by subtracting
elements from the frame. I'm terrible at subtracting from the
frame and a wide angle lens makes it even harder.
Yet I do not want to produce standard "postcard" photos. This list of tips
almost reads like an example of the things I try to
avoid when I'm shooting. That may be my very
problem, of course.
Dale Cotton
describes this as eye candy and says he wants photos with
staying power. "A sailboat alone on a still water at sunset may
make an eye-catching composition. Ten days after hanging it on your wall
you barely notice it. In twenty days it has become invisible. On the
other hand, visitors to your house are more likely to notice the
sailboat with delight than the less flashy image the endless detail of
which keeps amazing you with something new."
Now if I can just learn to produce those kinds of images....
29 Frames, Day 4