After practicing tennis until it got too dark to see, then walking
Maya, we sat down to watch that night's episode of Big Brother 5. I
checked the "My Shows" list but it wasn't there. Huh? I checked the
recording history and it says it wasn't recorded due to a conflict. But
there was only one other show (The Daily Show) scheduled to record at
that time. There are two tuners, so what's the problem?
It turns
out that there weren't two tuners — there was only one. The other tuner
had failed in the hardware, something that is apparently common in
UltimateTV devices. After two-and-a-half years of service, we needed to
get something new.
We're committed to DirecTV and love the
integration, so there wasn't much question: we would have to buy a
DirecTV with TiVo DVR. On the surface, there shouldn't be much
difference: both have two tuners, both have on-screen guides, both can
record shows, pause live TV, and both are integrated with DirecTV.
Sounds like it should mostly be a drop-in replacement.
Saturday
morning, I bought a Samsung 100-hour DirecTV with TiVo DVR at the
Crossroads Circuit City. This is a bonus: our Sony UltimateTV only had a
35-hour capacity.
I took it home. The connection was a breeze —
just plug the same cables that were in the UltimateTV into the TiVo and
walk through the setup process. Very smooth. We were watching TV in less
than a half an hour after I started the process.
But I've
discovered that the devices are not quite so similar as I had hoped. The
TiVo doesn't have a 30-second forward skip. Instead, I have to
fast-forward. That's just annoying, especially since the fast-forward
feature of the TiVo is designed for people with slow reaction times.
Once you see the part you want to watch and press play again, it backs
up a bit assuming you were slow. Well, it turns out I'm faster than
their target audience and so I end up watching the last 10 seconds or so
of the commercials I was trying to skip, even when I try to respond
more slowly. This is a huge problem with the TiVo device.
UltimateTV
also automatically started the recording a bit before the scheduled
time and let it run over a bit after to account for variations in TV
stations' schedules. It saved us from missing the very beginning or end
of shows many times. It's also smart enough to not let that extra time
cause conflicts and prevent adjacent shows from recording.
TiVo
doesn't have this automatic feature: you have to choose to enable it and
if you do, and that extra recording time (they call it "overtime")
would result in a conflict, it doesn't treat the overtime as separate:
whichever show is higher in the priority list wins. That's a problem,
although I'm not sure how big that will be.
Turning the device off
(or putting it in "standby" for the DirecTV TiVo device) requires
several steps: there's no way to do it with one button on the remote.
Instead, press the DirecTV button, press channel down to page down to
the last item in the list, and press Select. Urgh.
And speaking of
the user interface: it doesn't let you roll around to the top or
bottom. In well-designed programs, pressing down at the bottom of the
list causes the cursor to roll around to the top, and doing the same at
the top rolls around to the bottom. Instead, in the TiVo, I get the
error gong.
We'll have to learn to live with this device because
UltimateTV isn't sold any longer, but I'm surprised how frustrating
the interface feels. The way people have talked up TiVo in the past, I
thought it was a generation beyond UltimateTV.